Peyush Bansal’s explanation for the Lenskart bindi-hijab comparison that generated controversy earlier in the week has not, according to the pattern of continued social media discussion, resolved the situation. It has, instead, opened a second debate about whether the explanation was adequate.
For those who missed the original story: a social media post associated with Lenskart’s branding appeared to compare a Hindu woman wearing a bindi with a Muslim woman wearing a hijab in a context that several commenters read as suggesting the hijab was equivalent to the bindi as a religious accessory — a comparison that both pro-hijab and anti-hijab audiences found objectionable for opposite reasons.
What Bansal Said
The CEO posted a statement explaining the post’s intent — inclusivity, the celebration of diversity, the company’s respect for all religious identities. He described the framing as an expression of the India he believed in, where different communities’ expressions of faith coexist.
The response to the explanation: people who found the original post problematic found the explanation inadequate; people who supported the original sentiment found the controversy overblown; and a third group found the entire episode to be an example of corporate social media management failing to anticipate how content would be received across a diverse and polarised audience.
Why It Won’t Die Down
The bindi-hijab comparison touches a live wire in Indian public discourse because both symbols carry enormous political and religious weight that the “diversity and inclusion” framing can’t neutralise. The bindi is, for many Hindus, specifically a marker of Hindu religious identity that has been de-politicised through fashion but retains its original significance. The hijab is the subject of active legal and political contestation across multiple Indian states.
Putting them in the same frame, regardless of intent, activates the entire associated discourse. An explanation about inclusivity doesn’t turn down the voltage — it just adds another topic for the same controversy to absorb.
